About Our Agency

We are a family-owned and operated Independent insurance agency that has been providing superior insurance products, and service, to New Yorkers for over 37 years. We are part of a growing group, Consolidated Insurance Agents, Inc., that currently consists of 22 independent insurance agencies. This partnership provides incredible support, and it makes the opportunities endless.



Michael Mazzara, Owner / President

[email protected]
Your personal lines and commercial lines insurance expert





Michelle Prentice, Account Representative, Licensed agent

[email protected]

Michelle is a licensed insurance agent that handles all customer service duties. She has been with the agency for over 15 years!




Our primary objective is to establish a working relationship between you, the insurance company, and our staff so that we can assure quality protection, valued customer service, low rates, and superior claims service! As an Independent Insurance Agency, we represent several of the premier insurance companies in the region, but we work for you! The end result is always a competitive rate and a premier product. However, we pride ourselves on customer service, and years of dedicated, friendly service, have resulted in fantastic retention rates!

After we place your insurance with a particular company, we continue to work for you to the degree that you desire. Should you have a loss, we can take the claim report directly from you and follow through to see that you get a fair settlement. However, in these times of high technology, many companies have the capability to take reports directly from the insured via fax, phone, or email. So that option is available for you as well. Whether you contact us or the company directly, we are still available for any assistance that you may need!

Our clients are busy individuals and families who seek convenient, personal, affordable and hassle-free solutions for all of their insurance needs. We serve the insurance needs of hundreds of individuals, families, and businesses. Not only do most of our clients renew their policies, they also refer their family and friends!

You can visit us here 24 hours a day, or call our office during business hours. You'll be pleased you did. If you are already a client, thank you for coming aboard.

If you are not a client yet, we look forward to doing business with you soon!